Cookie subscriptions

A box of fresh-baked cookies to
celebrate with every month.

We offer our seasonal cookies in cookie subscription boxes. Get a dozen fresh-baked cookies in our specialty seasonal flavours every single month.

Our summer flavours

Blueberry Crumble Cookie

Oatmeal Raisin

Crispy on the outside, soft in the centre, with just a hint of cinnamon and packed with raisins.
Confetti Cookie

Confetti Sprinkle

A fan favourite here. Our soft vanilla sugar cookie with tons of colourful sprinkles.
Chocolate Chip Cookie

The 2 Chip

Our only cookie that remains on our menu year round is our chocolate chip filled with both milk and dark chocolate chips.

Toffee Pretzel Cookie

Toffee Pretzel

Filled with toffee and butterscotch for the sweet, and pretzels for the salt, these are the perfect balance.

Our subscriptions

Our subscriptions are currently closed.

A Tasty Box 

Monthly Cookie Subscription

A box of 12 cookies every month! What could be better? 

Starting at $28/box

A Tasty SEAson

3 Months of Cookies

Get a box of 12 delicious cookies every month, all season long! Make this Fall a little cozier.

Starting at $26/box

Michelle Baking

Meet the baker

Hello! My name is Michelle and baking is my passion! I have been baking in my family’s kitchen for as long as I can remember and can’t wait to bring our homemade feel to your door, without you having to turn on the oven! Baking reminds me of family, community and celebration, which is exactly what we focus on here at The Little Red Bake Shop.

As a person who takes baked goods very seriously, I had high expectations for my first cookie delivery from The Little Red Bake Shop. I was beyond impressed with every aspect of my experience. Not only were the cookies some of the best treats I’ve tasted but the care and love that went into every detail of the delivery made me feel incredibly special. Can’t wait to put in another order and share The Little Red Bake Shop treats with my friends and family.

Ashley F.

Frequently asked questions

What subscriptions are available?

There are two different plans available. In each plan, you are able to pick your flavours and your pickup/delivery dates.

Option 1: A Tasty Box (Monthly Subscription)
In our monthly subscription box, you choose your cookie flavours, pickup/delivery dates. Each month you get a box of 12 cookies without having to re-enter your order/payment information. You can choose to pick them up in store, have them delivered directly to your door (Aurora, Newmarket, East Gwillimbury, and Georgina only), or have them shipped to you (across Ontario).

Each month, your subscription will automatically renew on the first of the month, however, you can skip a month or cancel at any time. 

Option 2: A Tasty Season (3 Month Subscription)
In our 3-month subscription you will have our fresh-baked cookies once a month, made especially for that season. Our seasons are

  • Winter (December to February)
  • Spring (March to May)
  • Summer (June to August),
  • Fall (September to November)

Three months means three boxes of 12 cookies!

At the end of the season, your subscription will auto-renew on the 1st of the month (December, March, June, and September) or you can cancel at any time.

Will my subscription renew automatically?

Yes! Your subscription will renew automatically every month or every 3 months depending on the type of subscription you have chosen.

Each season you will have the opportunity to select your new flavours and select your pickup/delivery time. If we don’t hear from you, we will use the previous flavours specified when you subscribed or you will receive an assorted box of seasonal flavours.

You can cancel your subscription at any time on our “Account” page on our website.

Can I customize my order?

With all of our orders you get to pick which flavours are in your box, when you want it to be picked up/delivered, and where in our delivery area you would like it to be delivered to.


Want to change your flavour options each month? No problem! If you would like to change your cookie flavours before your next box just send us an email.

Need to change something about your order after it has gone through? Just let us know!

When can I pick up my boxes?

You can schedule your pickup days during any of our store hours. We are open Wednesday from 11am to 6pm, Thursday and Friday from 10am to 6pm, and Saturday from 10am to 2pm at 200 Mulock Drive, Unit 4, in Newmarket.

What are your delivery days and where do you deliver?

We deliver on the 2nd Friday,  the 4th Wednesday of every month to Aurora, Newmarket, East Gwillimbury and Georgina only.

We also ship our cookies Ontario Wide. Cookies are shipped out every Wednesday and Thursday with the goal that they will arrive by Friday latest. Please note, we cannot guarantee shipping times. 

What if I am not home when you deliver?

 If you know that you will not be home on your selected delivery day, please indicate in your delivery instructions where you would like your box left. We will leave it in your specified drop off spot.

Please consider the weather when thinking of your designated drop off spot. During snowy or rainy weather, we recommend putting out a bin for us to put your cookie box in to keep them dry. During the hotter months, the chocolate in our cookies may melt. Therefore we recommend not leaving them out for too long, or have us put the cookies inside the garage or in a shaded spot so they do not get too hot. 

We ask that if you are in an apartment building and are requesting we leave it with the concierge that you ensure food can be left with them.If we are unable to deliver your box, it will be expected that you will pick it up from our storefront, or another delivery date can be scheduled for an additional fee.

How do I update my delivery address and payment information?

To update your credit card information or to see your order history, scroll down to the bottom of our page and click on “Account.” Ensure you are logged in.

On the left-hand side you will see a menu with options to edit and update any information needed.

To change your delivery address or to send one of your boxes to a friend, please send an email to hello@thelittleredbakeshop.com and we would be happy to help you.

Can I change the delivery address every month?

If you are looking to send a thank you to a client, coworker, friend, or all around amazing person every month, we would love to make that happen! Our cookies are all about connecting people together.  Please email the new address to us at least one week prior to your scheduled delivery date each month.

Is your packaging environmentally friendly?

We are continuously working on finding more sustainable and eco-friendly solutions for our packaging. We are currently using recyclable paper boxes lined with biodegradable natural parchment paper for our cookie boxes.

We are using recycled paper for our postcards and recyclable paper bags for all of our deliveries.

For our subscribers, we are looking into a reusable container, though we have not yet launched this program.

If you have a suggestion, we want to hear it! Please send an email to hello@thelittleredbakeshop.com.

How long will my cookies be fresh for?

All of our cookies will last approximately 5 days in our paper boxes. To lengthen their freshness, place them in an airtight container and keep them at room temperature for approximately 8 days (if you don’t eat them before then!). However, our fresh fruit cookies should remain in our paper box as tupperware and plastic bags are too humid for the fresh fruit and will shorten their freshness period.

Our cookies can also be frozen. Just wrap them and place them in an airtight container in the freezer. When you are ready to have them, enjoy them cold or let them defrost for approximately 1 hour before eating them. For a fresh from the oven feel, you can then heat them briefly in the microwave for a ooey-gooey feel.

Want some more ideas for ways to enjoy your cookies? Join our newsletter for easy ideas to make your cookies even more delicious. (Did someone say Ice Cream Sandwiches?!)

What are your sanitation practices? Do you use a health inspected kitchen?

Your safety is our number one concern — well, that and deliciousness, of course! We care about your health and wellbeing like you’re a part of our family.

We are baking in a commercial, health inspected kitchen. 

We follow York Region Public Health’s guidelines and YorkSafe. We ensure that our Food Handlers Certificate is always up to date.

We are also following all recommended protocols for COVID-19, including closing the bakery if we are sick. We have increased the frequency of our already rigorous hand washing procedures as well. All surfaces our products, boxes and bags come into contact with are thoroughly cleaned before, during, and after our cookie production.

Our staff also use COVID Rapid Test approximately once per week, to ensure our safety, and yours.

I have allergies, am I okay to eat your cookies?

We love baking for you, but we do not bake in an allergen-free kitchen. While we do rigorously clean all of our equipment frequently, we cannot guarantee our kitchen is free of any of the major allergens. All of our cookies contain wheat, dairy, and eggs. While most of our cookies do not use any ingredients with a may contain warning for nuts, we are not a nut free facility.

If you have allergies, we ask that you use your own discretion when ordering and to disclose any allergies or sensitivities when you order. Feel free to call or email us with your questions.

Get your cookies now!

A Tasty Box

Monthly Subscription Box

A box of cookies every month! What could be better? Choose which cookies you want in your box and leave the rest to us!

Starting at $28/box

A Tasty Season

3 Boxes of Cookies

Get a box of 12 delicious cookies every month, all season long! Make this Spring a little sweeter.

Starting at $26/box