Sugar cookies

Tasty designs made especially
for you.

Our sugar cookies are baked, designed, and decorated specifically for you.

Perfect for any event or special occasion, our sugar cookies add a delicious work of art to your gathering — and they can be made in vanilla or chocolate.

During our consultation we will create a custom plan for your beautiful treats, from a special theme or colour to your company’s logo.

We look forward to making these for you!

Image of hand-painted unicorn vanilla sugar cookies sitting on a cooling rack

Image of vanilla sugar cookies in the shape of a baby's onesie painted pink.

How it works

Plan Your Cookies

Fill out our short Cookie Quote Form! Then, we’ll have a consultation, check our availability, and confirm all the delicious details of your cookie order. Sugar cookies range in price and a quote will be given based on your needs.

Celebrate in Style!

We will deliver your beautiful treats in time for you to celebrate in style in the most delicious way! (Or we’ll deliver them to your client, friend, or special person so they can celebrate, too.)

Start Your Order Now

Please note: We typically book about one month in advance but may still have some spots available in January.

Meet the baker

Hello! My name is Michelle and baking is my passion! I started baking as a kid with my family and continued to learn and polish my baking skills as I grew older. I love being able to take an idea and transform it onto a piece of art on a cookie, which is my goal with each set of decorated sugar cookies.

Kind and caring doesn’t even begin to describe the type of service I have received from Michelle at The Little Red Bake Shop. She does all that she can to make you feel satisfied as a customer. I ordered cookies for my mom for Mother’s Day and they were a HIT! She was attentive to the details of my order, made sure that I was happy with all aspects before we finalized, and the cookies were delicious! I will be ordering from her again very soon.

Laura G.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a minimum order amount?

Our minimum order amount is 1 dozen (12) cookies.

What flavour choices are there?

Our sugar cookies are available in both vanilla (with a hint of cinnamon) and chocolate. They must be ordered in a minimum of a dozen per flavour.

What are my packaging options?

We offer two different packaging options. Your sugar cookies can either come in our recyclable kraft box, or they can be individually wrapped in our cellophane bags. Please note that prices do differ depending on packaging requests. Packaging add-ons are available, such as ribbon on the cellophane bags. We will go over packaging options and costs during our consultation.

How long will my sugar cookies last?

The sugar cookies wrapped in sealed cellophane bags will last the longest (at room temperature up to four weeks). In our kraft boxes the sugar cookies will stay fresh for one week at room temperature. To lengthen the life of your sugar cookies, we recommend putting them in an airtight Tupperware container, where they can last several weeks. Our sugar cookies also freeze well, if you happen to have any left over.

What are your delivery days and where do you deliver?

We deliver our regular cookies on the 2nd Friday and 4th Wednesday of every month and are happy to add your custom cookies to our delivery route if the dates line up. We delivery throughout York Region only.

If those delivery dates do not line up with your order, we would ask that you pick up your order at our bakery during our business hours.

What if I am not home when you deliver?

We do ask that you try to be home when we deliver, so pick your order time accordingly.

If you are not home, we will leave it in your specified drop off spot, that you will give us during the consultation. Please consider the weather when thinking of your drop off spot. During the hotter weather, the heat can melt the icing on the sugar cookies, so it is not recommended they are left out for long.

We ask that if you are in an apartment building and are requesting we leave it with the concierge that you ensure food can be left with them.

What are your sanitation practices? Do you use a health inspected kitchen

Your safety is our number one concern — well, that and deliciousness, of course! We care about your health and wellbeing like you’re a part of our family.

We are currently baking in a commercial, health inspected kitchen.

We follow York Region Public Health’s guidelines and YorkSafe. We ensure that our Food Handlers Certificate is always up to date.

Currently, we are also following all recommended protocols for COVID-19. Masks are worn during preparation, baking, packaging and delivery. We have increased the frequency of our already rigorous hand washing procedures as well. All surfaces our products, boxes and bags come into contact with are thoroughly cleaned before, during, and after our cookie production.

I have allergies, am I okay to eat your cookies?

We love baking for you, but we do not bake in an allergen-free kitchen. While we do rigorously clean all of our equipment frequently, we do not guarantee gluten, wheat, egg, or nut-free products. Please also note that most food colour has a may contain warning for most allergens, and therefore any coloured designed will have the same may contain warnings.

If you have allergies, we ask that you use your own discretion when ordering and to disclose any allergies or sensitivities when you order.