fbpx

Cookies that
taste like home

Freshly baked cookies,
from our family to yours.

Welcome to The Little Red Bake Shop where we are all about celebrating your wins and appreciating those around you with delicious baked goods that taste like home.

Located at 200 Mulock Drive, Unit 4, in Newmarket.

905 251-3578

Store Hours

We are currently do not have ‘open hours’, however we are at the East Gwillimbury Farmers Market every Thursday from 2:00-7:00pm, located at 19000 Leslie St, Sharon (by the Sharon Temple). 

We are also always accepting custom orders so feel free to reach out if you are looking for a larger quantity or our sugar cookies for pickup on a day other than Thursday.

We also deliver our tasty treats across Ontario, made with the best ingredients (and a little extra dash of love).

Fall Cookie Flavours

Order Your Cookies!

Whether it’s a 3 pack, 6 pack, or box of a dozen, we have the perfect dessert for you! Choose from our current cookie menu, including our toffee pretzel cookies, and mix and match however you would like! Pickup on  Friday, evenings from 4:00-6:00pm. 

Our spring flavours

(Now until May)

Blueberry Crumble Cookie

Oatmeal Raisin

Crispy on the outside, soft in the centre, with just a hint of cinnamon and packed with raisins.
Confetti Cookie

Confetti Sprinkle

A fan favourite here. Our soft vanilla sugar cookie with tons of colourful sprinkles.
Chocolate Chip Cookie

The 2 Chip

Our only cookie that remains on our menu year round is our chocolate chip filled with both milk and dark chocolate chips.

Toffee Pretzel Cookie

Toffee Pretzel

Filled with toffee and butterscotch for the sweet, and pretzels for the salt, these are the perfect balance.

Single Cookie Boxes

Celebrate a special moment (or a special someone!) with a box of a dozen fresh-baked cookies delivered right to your door.

Cookie Subscription Boxes

Get 12 of our amazing seasonal cookies, fresh-baked and delivered every month.

Custom Sugar Cookies

Sugar cookies designed, baked, and decorated especially for you! Perfect for special occasions or client gifts.

Thank you The Little Red Bake Shop for providing us with amazing sugar cookies for our trade show! Michelle individually hand piped our logo onto every cookie and we received so much positive feedback on the cookies (for both the taste and look). An amazing giveaway for our trade show; highly, highly recommend!

Shannon W.

Michelle Laughing

Meet the baker

Hello! My name is Michelle and baking is my passion! I started baking as a kid with my family. For us, it was all about family time, celebration, and sharing the recipes that have been passed down through generations. And this exactly what we aim to do with our cookies now! To create moments of celebration, with the ones you love, and some real, homemade, delicious cookies. 

Join our cookie community on social media!